The Law on our Hearts
Jeremiah 31:33-34 reads, "But this is the covenant that I will make with the house of Israel after those days, declares the Lord: I will put my law within them, and I will write it on their hearts. And I will be their God and they shall be my people. And no longer shall each one teach his neighbor and each his brother, saying, 'Know the Lord,' for they shall all know me, from the least of them to the greatest, declares the Lord. For I will forgive their iniquity, and I will remember their sin no more." (ESV)
Here the Lord speaks of the New Covenant He will make with His people, a covenant different from the Mosaic covenant that they broke. Instead He will put the law on their hearts and forgive them their iniquity and sin. So here's my question for you all: What is the 'law' he is speaking of writing on our hearts? This passage is reference twice in the NT, once in Heb. 10:16-17 where it is quoted directly, and Rom. 2:15 (note also preceding and following verses) where the 'law is written on their hearts' is again referred to. It seems, especially in the Romans text, that this is referring to the 'natural law' that is evident to all mankind apart from specific revelation, by which all mankind is held guilty before God for sin. This text also seems to put no limit on the timeframe in which this law on our hearts exists (i.e. before the New Covenant). However, the Jeremiah text seems to refer to this law written on the hearts that is something that is specifically revealed and within a timeframe (i.e. at the institution of the New Covenant). So again my question is what the 'law written on the hearts' of the New Covenant is. The Hebrews passage seems to deal more directly with the Jeremiah passage, and explicitly connecting the New Covenant to Jesus' one perfect sacrifice. So is the law here 'law' in the broad sense of God's Word as a whole, inclusive of both Law and Gospel? (cf. the Formula of Concord article V explanation of the Scripture's use of law--strictly speaking, and gospel--strictly speaking vs. their broad sense). Or is the law on our hearts (accd. to Jer. 31:33) the law strictly speaking, as God's commandments and precepts? Why then is it speaking of forgiveness? I appreciate your feedback on this question.
Here the Lord speaks of the New Covenant He will make with His people, a covenant different from the Mosaic covenant that they broke. Instead He will put the law on their hearts and forgive them their iniquity and sin. So here's my question for you all: What is the 'law' he is speaking of writing on our hearts? This passage is reference twice in the NT, once in Heb. 10:16-17 where it is quoted directly, and Rom. 2:15 (note also preceding and following verses) where the 'law is written on their hearts' is again referred to. It seems, especially in the Romans text, that this is referring to the 'natural law' that is evident to all mankind apart from specific revelation, by which all mankind is held guilty before God for sin. This text also seems to put no limit on the timeframe in which this law on our hearts exists (i.e. before the New Covenant). However, the Jeremiah text seems to refer to this law written on the hearts that is something that is specifically revealed and within a timeframe (i.e. at the institution of the New Covenant). So again my question is what the 'law written on the hearts' of the New Covenant is. The Hebrews passage seems to deal more directly with the Jeremiah passage, and explicitly connecting the New Covenant to Jesus' one perfect sacrifice. So is the law here 'law' in the broad sense of God's Word as a whole, inclusive of both Law and Gospel? (cf. the Formula of Concord article V explanation of the Scripture's use of law--strictly speaking, and gospel--strictly speaking vs. their broad sense). Or is the law on our hearts (accd. to Jer. 31:33) the law strictly speaking, as God's commandments and precepts? Why then is it speaking of forgiveness? I appreciate your feedback on this question.
Comments
I don't think we can simply flip the words and say that the Law of God (Rom. 7:25) is really the Gospel. First of all, the Romans 7 text is speaking of the spirit-flesh struggle of the new believer in sanctification, and the 'law of God' that he delights in, in his inner being is the law that teaches him the good things that he wants to do. So this law of God, teaches him the good he ought to do, but it does not enable him to do so. As such, it cannot be the Gospel, for the Gospel refers to Christ's action not ours, and IS what enables us to do good.
Which brings us back to Jeremiah 31 and Heb. 10. The Law written on the heart, (same law as Rom. 7:22) must be actually law. But what distinguishes the Old Covenant from the New seems to be that the Old Covenant was law given externally, which no one kept. The New Covenant, is defined by forgiveness of sins (Jer. 31:34), but also includes the giving of the Law internally. Jeremiah doesn't seem to indicate that this Law on our hearts will be the basis of salvation, but rather the forgiveness. The Law has no part in justifying faith (Gal. 3:12), but faith does not abolish the law, but rather upholds it (Rom. 3:31). This last paragraph I was helped considerably by consulting Walther's Law/Gospel and Pieper's Dogmatics today, regarding those verses. They didn't give an entirely satisfying explanation of my question, but helped elucidate those last few points.
So what do you think? This explanation leaves the law on the hearts as law, but along with the text gives no justifying value to the law.
May the peace of the universal spirit bless you
Swami Shyamananda
seductionsalvation.blogspot.com
>>>
To Serendip man: if you really understood Jesus Christ's teachings, you could not be as 'at home' with him as with Buddha or Krishna. Jesus taught that He was the *ONLY* way to the Father (John 14:6). There is only one God and one way to salvation, and that is through Jesus Christ.
The forgiveness of sins on the other hand is the forensic benefit we have in Christ as He forgives all our sins and accepts us as righteous in His sight through our having His verdict rendered to our account. So it's Jsutification and Sanctification. It acquittal and renovation. It is peace with God and victory over sin. It is acceptance and deliverance. Peace, Phil Hodson